Our Menu
House Favorites
-
A buttermilk Korean fried chicken sandwich stacked with lettuce, tomato, pickles, and our signature Brooklyn Picante Sauce. Crispy, juicy, and bursting with flavor — the chicken sandwich of your dreams.
-
A golden, crispy chicken shell that’s as versatile as it is delicious! Choose from the Original Blend like fresh lettuce, sour cream, diced tomatoes, and spicy sauce, or go with classic pasta favorites tucked inside this unique creation. A perfect fusion of crunch and flavor, crafted just for you!
-
From our all-new Skinny Deep Dish line — half the thickness of a traditional deep dish and packed with a ton of flavor! Built on our naturally leavened sourdough crust for lightness, depth, and that signature crisp edge. Featuring a creamy homemade vodka sauce base, fresh mozzarella, charred pepperoni cups, rich burrata, and a sprinkle of basil. Finished with a caramelized cheese crown that stretches to the edge, it’s deep dish reimagined — inspired by Sorrento, Italy, and absolutely unforgettable.
-
Our 100% naturally leavened sourdough is fermented low and slow for deeper flavor, a lighter texture, and the BIGGEST crunch. Topped with creamy in-house made Brooklyn mix, grilled chicken, Grande mozzarella, and fresh cilantro, then baked until perfectly golden for a rich, smoky, and unforgettable bite.
-
Handcrafted and fried to golden perfection, these in-house made mozzarella triangles are filled with gooey, melty cheese and served with a side of our signature zesty marinara sauce. A new take on classic mozzarella sticks done the Brooklyn way!
-
Golden crispy chicken fried in 100% beef tallow, layered with crisp lettuce, fresh tomatoes, sliced onions, and our signature Brooklyn Sauce, then wrapped in a warm grilled tortilla.
Our Story
Since taking over Brooklyn Pizza in 2019, Chef Jose Rodriguez has transformed the restaurant through an unwavering commitment to quality, craftsmanship, and innovation. Inspired by the timeless traditions of Brooklyn pizzerias while embracing his own culinary roots, Jose built the menu around naturally leavened sourdough, premium ingredients, and time-honored techniques that allow every flavor to shine. From classic New York favorites to creative signature pizzas, every dish reflects his passion for doing things the right way, earning Brooklyn Pizza a reputation as a destination for exceptional pizza in Short Hills, New Jersey.
